When it comes to selecting a diamond for an engagement ring or any other piece of jewelry, one of the most important decisions to make is the shape of the diamond. Each shape offers unique advantages and potential drawbacks, depending on factors like personal preference, style, and budget. In this article, we’ll explore the pros and cons of some of the most popular diamonds shapes pros and cons to help you make an informed choice.
Table of Contents
Round Brilliant Cut: The Classic Choice
The round brilliant cut is by far the most popular and classic diamond shape. Known for its exceptional brilliance and timeless appeal, it has been the go-to choice for engagement rings for decades.
Pros: The round brilliant cut is designed to maximize sparkle due to its 58 facets, which create a lot of light dispersion. This shape tends to look bigger than other shapes of the same carat weight because of its proportional symmetry. Additionally, it works well in almost any setting and is versatile in terms of style.
Cons: One of the major drawbacks of the round brilliant cut is its cost. Because of its popularity and demand, round diamonds are often more expensive than other shapes. Additionally, since a lot of diamond material is lost during the cutting process, round brilliant diamonds typically offer less carat weight for the price when compared to other shapes.
Princess Cut: Modern and Bold
The princess cut is a square or rectangular-shaped diamond that offers a modern, chic look. This shape is known for its sharp, clean lines and contemporary style.
Pros: Princess cut diamonds offer a lot of brilliance and sparkle, similar to the round brilliant cut, but at a more affordable price. The shape also tends to look larger compared to its carat weight, making it a great option for those who want a larger-looking diamond at a lower price point. Additionally, its angular shape works well with modern settings and can be set in both traditional and contemporary designs.
Cons: One of the biggest downsides of the princess cut is its corners, which are more prone to chipping or damage. It’s important to choose a setting that will protect the corners from impact. Additionally, the shape doesn’t always exhibit the same level of brilliance as a round diamond, especially if the diamond is cut poorly.
Cushion Cut: Vintage Elegance
The cushion cut is a square or rectangular diamond with rounded corners, giving it a softer, vintage look. It combines the brilliance of the round cut with the charm of an older-style diamond.
Pros: Cushion cut diamonds are highly popular for their romantic, vintage appeal. They offer a larger surface area compared to other shapes, which makes them look bigger. This shape also tends to showcase excellent light reflection, giving it a beautiful sparkle. The cushion cut is versatile and can suit many types of settings, from antique to modern designs.
Cons: The cushion cut can sometimes appear less brilliant than a round diamond because of its shape, especially in diamonds with lower quality cuts. It may also have less fire (the dispersion of light into colors) than other cuts. In addition, this shape can be more prone to showing inclusions, so it’s essential to choose a higher-quality cushion cut diamond.
Emerald Cut: Timeless and Elegant
The emerald cut is a rectangular shape with stepped facets, creating a hall-of-mirrors effect. This cut emphasizes clarity over brilliance and is known for its elegant, sophisticated appearance.
Pros: Emerald cut diamonds are known for their stunning, sophisticated look and elegant, elongated shape. This cut offers a unique, bold appearance, and because it highlights the diamond’s clarity, it’s ideal for those who want a diamond that showcases purity and transparency. It also tends to appear larger than other shapes because of its elongated surface.
Cons: One of the main drawbacks of the emerald cut is its lack of brilliance. Because of its large, open facets, it doesn’t produce as much sparkle as other shapes, such as the round or princess cut. Additionally, emerald cut diamonds show inclusions and flaws more prominently than other shapes, so it’s important to choose a high-quality diamond with excellent clarity.
Oval Cut: Elongated and Elegant
The oval cut is similar to the round brilliant cut but features an elongated shape. This cut is known for its graceful and elegant appearance.
Pros: Oval diamonds offer the brilliance of a round diamond but with the added benefit of an elongated shape that can make fingers look longer and slimmer. They tend to appear larger for their carat weight due to their elongated surface area. This shape also tends to be less expensive than round diamonds, offering good value for those seeking brilliance at a more affordable price.
Cons: The oval cut can sometimes exhibit a “bow-tie” effect, where the center of the diamond appears darker due to the way light reflects off the facets. It’s essential to choose an oval cut diamond with a good proportion and symmetry to minimize this effect. Additionally, like the round cut, oval diamonds are relatively expensive, though they still offer some cost savings compared to round diamonds.
Asscher Cut: Vintage and Bold
The asscher cut is a square shape with deep, step-cut facets. It is often considered a more vintage style due to its early popularity in the early 20th century.
Pros: The asscher cut is known for its dramatic, vintage appeal and is ideal for those who want a unique, classic diamond. Its symmetry and clean lines create a bold look that stands out. Like the emerald cut, the asscher cut highlights clarity and transparency. The square shape also tends to look larger than other shapes of the same carat weight.
Cons: Like the emerald cut, asscher diamonds lack the sparkle and brilliance of round diamonds, making them less ideal for those seeking a diamond with more fire. Additionally, asscher cut diamonds can show inclusions more easily, so it’s important to select a high-quality diamond with excellent clarity to ensure the best appearance.
Pear Cut: Unique and Elegant
The pear cut is a teardrop-shaped diamond that combines the round and marquise cuts. It is a unique and elegant option for those who want something different from the traditional shapes.
Pros: The pear cut offers a distinctive, elegant appearance and can make the finger appear longer and slimmer due to its elongated shape. It also offers good brilliance, especially when cut well. Pear-shaped diamonds are versatile and can be set in many different types of jewelry, from engagement rings to pendants.
Cons: One of the main drawbacks of the pear cut is its tendency to show flaws and inclusions more easily, particularly at the point of the diamond. The shape can also be challenging to set properly, as it requires a secure setting to avoid damage to the pointed end. Additionally, the pear cut can sometimes exhibit the bow-tie effect if not cut well.
Marquise Cut: Dramatic and Eye-Catching
The marquise cut is an elongated diamond shape with pointed ends, resembling the shape of a football. Known for its dramatic and striking appearance, it’s a unique and bold choice.
Pros: The marquise cut is known for its dramatic and elongated shape, making it an eye-catching choice for those who want a diamond that stands out. The shape can create the illusion of a larger diamond and can make fingers appear longer and more slender. Marquise diamonds are also relatively affordable compared to round lab diamonds.
Cons: The main drawback of the marquise cut is its vulnerability to damage at the pointed ends, which can easily chip if not set properly. Like the pear cut, it can also show inclusions more prominently at the ends. Additionally, the shape can sometimes appear less brilliant than round or princess diamonds, depending on the quality of the cut.
Conclusion: Choosing the Right Diamond Shape
Choosing the right diamond shape ultimately depends on personal preferences, style, and budget. Each shape has its unique set of advantages and potential drawbacks, so it’s important to carefully consider what you want in terms of brilliance, size, and appearance. Whether you choose a classic round brilliant cut, a bold princess cut, or an elegant emerald cut, make sure to select a shape that reflects your taste and suits the occasion. By understanding the pros and cons of each diamond shape, you can make a confident, informed decision that ensures you’re happy with your choice for years to come.